fbpx
    09 Apr 2021

    A Parking Dispute At a Condo Ends in a Precedent Setting $1500 Payout Featured

    A condominium Declaration is a collection of documents that allow a condominium corporation to be formed and explains what a condo owner's common elements are and how much they'll pay for their maintenance.

    Common elements are those parts of a condo complex that belong to all owners. If someone purchases a condo, they become part of a larger collective of owners who all share an interest in the condo corporation and its operations. These documents are instrumental in establishing rules for the unit owners, how the condo corporation conducts its business and the management of the condo's affairs.

    On October 2, 2020, the powers of the Condominium Authority Tribunal (the “CAT”) were expanded to include the types of disputes it can hear under the Condominium Act, 1998 (the “Act”). The Condominium Act is an Ontario provincial legislation that regulates most aspects of condo formation, purchasing, living in, and governance. Now the CAT can hear disputes concerning parking, storage, and vehicles, among other things. For example, this recent case, Rahman v Peel Standard Condominium Corporation No. 779, was decided under the CAT’s expanded jurisdiction. In this case, the CAT interpreted the condominium corporation’s Declaration with respect to parking.

    For the reasons outlined below, this case makes it clear that a condo corporation cannot unilaterally and arbitrarily impose costs incurred to enforce compliance with its Declaration as “common expenses” without a court order. 

    Mr. Rahman was the owner of a condo unit and two parking spots in the condominium. Due to a disability, Mr. Rahman was unable to use either of his parking spots and instead, parked in one of the accessible parking spots in the outdoor lot. Whenever he parked in an accessible spot, he always displayed the Accessible Parking Pass that he obtained lawfully from the Province of Ontario. Mr. Rahman’s disability was supported by a letter from his doctor which also established that his disability qualified his use of an Accessible Parking Pass. At the hearing, Mr. Rahman’s position was that the condo’s Declaration entitled him to use the accessible parking spots available and that he wasn't asking for the condo to accommodate him. 

    The condo took the position that Mr. Rahman breached the Declaration because he parked in visitor, not accessible parking and that he failed to provide sufficient evidence to justify his use of accessible parking. As such, the condo commenced legal actions for costs it incurred to enforce Mr. Rahman’s compliance with its Declaration, including the registration of a lien on the title to Mr. Rahman’s unit and effecting a Notice of Sale, basically threatening eviction from the condominium.

    These enforcement actions were undertaken without a court order, which violated the rules of the Condominium Act. Under section 134(5) of the Act, a court order is required before a condo corporation’s legal enforcement costs can be added to a unitholder’s common expenses. The condo corporation not only added its enforcement costs to Mr. Rahman’s common expenses, but they did so by way of a lien and a notice of sale in violation of this section. The CAT disagreed with the condo, finding that Mr. Rahman was in his rights to park in an accessible spot and that the only accessible spot available to owners was where Mr. Rahman parked. As a result, Mr. Rahman was not in violation of the condo’s Declaration and the condo corporation was ordered to stop any enforcement action it undertook. Additionally, The CAT determined that these actions were aggressive and amounted to harassment, for which Mr. Rahman was awarded $1,500. 

    WHY THIS CASE MATTERS 

    With the expanded powers and jurisdiction of the CAT, parties may not have to resort to costly private mediation, arbitration, or the Court, to obtain relief in condo disputes. The expansion of powers will allow for more disputes to be heard by the CAT and, potentially, in a timelier manner. 

    In this case, the CAT is sending a message to condo corporations that they cannot unilaterally and arbitrarily impose costs of enforcement on a unitholder under the guise of “common expenses” without a court order. The Act does not serve to protect one party at the expense of another, and it cannot be used to widen the inherent power imbalance between a condo corporation and its unit owners. 

    However, it sets precedent for any future disputes and is game-changing for the relationship between a unitholder and a condominium in Ontario.

     

    Read 527 times Last modified on Sunday, 18 April 2021 12:01
    (2 votes)
    Walker Law Professional Corporation

    Tanya Walker obtained her law degree from Osgoode Hall at York University in 2005 and her Honours Bachelor of Commerce with a minor in Economics from McMaster University in 2002. She was called to the Ontario Bar in 2006 and created Walker Law a litigation law firm in 2010. Tanya is currently serving a term as Bencher of the Law Society of Ontario; elected by her peers as not only the first Black elected female Bencher from Toronto, in the 220-year history of the Law Society, but also as one of the youngest sitting Benchers.
 Tanya is a frequent speaker on legal issues to the Toronto Community and regularly appears on the CTV Show, Your Morning as a legal expert. She has also been named in the 2017 and 2018 Lexpert Guides as one of the Leading Lawyers to Watch in Corporate/Commercial Litigation and is also the recipient of the 2018 Women’s Business Enterprise of the Year Award.

 Tel: 647-342-2334 ext. 302 
 Email: tanya(at)tcwalkerlawyers.com

    tcwalkerlawyers.com/

    Featured Directory Listings

    Featured events

     

    3li En Wordmark C

    About ByBlacks.com

    Image

    ByBlacks.com is the top-ranked award-winning online magazine focused exclusively on telling Black Canadian stories. With over one hundred writers to date covering a range of editorial content, we also provide a free business directory for Black Canadian owned businesses, free events listing and promotional services for our clients.

    Image

    Subscribe

    Follow Us:

    Search