SECTIONS CLOSE
  • Home
  • Directory
    • Artists
    • Black Youth & Family Services
    • Books
    • Business
    • Films
    • Politicians
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
    • Books
    • Film & TV
    • Music
    • Stage
  • The Experts
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Legal
    • Marketing
    • Money
    • Motivation
    • Parenting
    • Real Estate
    • Sex & Relationships
    • Technology
    • Travel
  • Profiles
    • Artists
    • Business
    • NFP/Charities
    • Personalities
    • Food & Drink
    • Sponsored Profiles
  • The Father Project
    • Fathers Responses
  • Archive
  • Newsletter Archive
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • PCA
    • 2024 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2023 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2022 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2021 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2020 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2019 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2018 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
  • Restaurant Week
    • 2025 BRW Best Booth Contest
    • Prix Fixe Menus
      • Prix Fixe Menus - AB
      • Prix Fixe Menus - BC
      • Prix Fixe Menus - NS
      • Prix Fixe Menus - NB
      • Prix Fixe Menus - ON
      • Prix Fixe Menus - PEI
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Editorial
  • General
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sales
  • User Login

ByBlacks.com | #1 online magazine for Black Canadians

Legal

Caribbean Restaurant Wins In Court Facing Landlord's Racist Actions

Caribbean Restaurant Wins In Court Facing Landlord's Racist Actions
Walker Law Professional Corporation By Walker Law Professional Corporation
Published on Friday, October 9, 2020 - 11:49
The recent case Elias Restaurant v Keele Sheppard Plaza Inc., 2020 ONSC 5457 involved a commercial landlord-tenant dispute between a Black owned restaurant tenant and its plaza landlord. The Tenant, Elias Restaurant is owned by a Black married couple and serves African/Caribbean cultural food. It caters primarily, but not exclusively, to a Black community customer base. This use of the premises was completely consistent with the terms of the lease.

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, when other restaurants’ bottom lines were suffering, Elias maintained a bustling takeout business and never missed a rent payment. Additionally, the restaurant invested approximately $150,000 in renovations over the course of the tenancy to make the premises suitable for their restaurant’s needs.

As the lease term was coming to an end, the Tenant wished to exercise their option to renew the lease for another five years and made several efforts to communicate this to the Landlord. However, the Landlord decided that it wished to replace the Tenant with someone more suitable to attract “like-minded family-oriented customers.” As a result, the Landlord deliberately ignored and avoided communicating with the Tenant regarding the lease renewal. Justice Morgan described the landlord’s suggestions that the restaurant owners were “unattractive” tenants as a form of 'Othering’ of minority people . . . in the guise of a legal method.”

The judge agreed with the restaurant that it was denied its right to renew not because of anything it did or anything within its control. The Court took the case one step further and accepted as fact, there is the existence of anti-black racism in Canadian society. “Identifying a family-run restaurant as not family-friendly, and impugning a restaurant-bar for serving ‘liquor’ and having smokers stand outside the premises, all point to a mindset that condemns the minority population for what is considered normal behaviour for the majority population,” said the judge.

Ordering a party to reinstate a lease is discretionary, so the Court looked at what would happen if the lease was terminated. From the Tenant’s perspective, they would lose their substantial investment, goodwill, and dignity due to prejudice. The Court ordered that the lease be renewed for five years and prevented the Landlord from terminating the lease unless the tenant has caused a breach of the lease.

WHY THIS CASE MATTERS
Courts do not usually interfere in commercial leases unless the lease would result in extreme unfairness to one party. If you can establish racism or discrimination and no legal wrongdoing on your part, the other side may be ordered to continue to conduct business with you. Although the Landlord did not say or do anything explicitly racist, the landlord’s behaviour was so obviously racially motivated that the Court barely had to read between the lines to decide in favour of the Tenant. Freedom of contract allows one to contract for many things, but discrimination is not one of them. This one case sent a strong message to Canadians that discrimination has no place in society nor the courts.

Tanya Walker obtained her law degree from Osgoode Hall at York University in 2005 and her Honours Bachelor of Commerce with a minor in Economics from McMaster University in 2002. She was called to the Ontario Bar in 2006 and created Walker Law a litigation law firm in 2010.

Tanya is currently serving a term as Bencher of the Law Society of Ontario; elected by her peers as not only the first Black elected female Bencher from Toronto, in the 220-year history of the Law Society, but also as one of the youngest sitting Benchers.
 Tanya is a frequent speaker on legal issues to the Toronto Community and regularly appears on the CTV Show, Your Morning as a legal expert. She has also been named in the 2017 and 2018 Lexpert Guides as one of the Leading Lawyers to Watch in Corporate/Commercial Litigation and is also the recipient of the 2018 Women’s Business Enterprise of the Year Award.

 Tel: 647-342-2334 ext. 302 
 Email: tanya(at)tcwalkerlawyers.com.

Last modified on Friday, October 9, 2020 - 13:22

Featured Directory Listings

  • GMS Professional Corporation Chartered Professional Accountants
    GMS Professional...https://gmscpa.ca/Name: GMS Professional Corporation Chartered Professional Acc...
  • Frontlines TO
    Frontlines TOfrontlines.toName: Frontlines TO
  • Oya Black Arts Coalition (OBAC)
    Oya Black Arts...https:/...Name: Oya Black Arts Coalition (OBAC)
  • Becoming Institute Inc.
    Becoming Institute...https:/...Name: Becoming Institute Inc.
  • Hudson Law Office Professional Corporation
    Hudson Law Office...Name: Hudson Law Office Professional Corporation
  • SEE ALL LISTINGS
  • TANYA WALKER
Walker Law Professional Corporation By Walker Law Professional Corporation

Latest from Walker Law Professional Corporation

  • “Go Back To Work Slave.” Ontario Human Rights Tribunal Awards Black Woman Just $250 In Damages For Racist Comment
  • Racial Profiling at the Airport: A Closer Look at the Edwards Case
  • Fired CFO Awarded Over $640K After Discrimination Battle
  • The Right To Know: Why Failed Police Applicants Deserve An Explanation
  • Ontario Company Sues Black Employee For Speaking Publicly About Racism In The Workplace

MORE IN THIS CATEGORY

Ontario Intends To Freeze Residential Rents This Fall, Will It Prevent A Wave of Increased Homelessness?
Ontario Intends To Freeze Residential Rents This Fall, Will It Prevent A Wave of Increased Homelessness? 14 September 2020
Disposing Your Assets If You Are Being Sued: A Short-Sighted Solution 12 November 2020
Disposing Your Assets If You Are Being Sued: A Short-Sighted Solution

RELATED STORIES

Emancipation Day: How Did Canadian Courts Help To Phase Out Slavery?

Emancipation Day: How Did Canadian Courts Help To Phase Out Slavery?

09 July 2022
The Risks Of Backing Out Of A Real Estate Transaction

The Risks Of Backing Out Of A Real Estate Transaction

30 May 2022
Breaking Barriers in The Supreme Court: Justice Jamal and Justice Jackson Make History

Breaking Barriers in The Supreme Court: Justice Jamal and Justice Jackson Make History

18 April 2022
ByBlacks.com | #1 online magazine for Black Canadians
Magazines Canada
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Editorial
  • General
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sales
  • User Login
Copyright © 2013 - 2025 ByBlacks.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
developed by Nuevvo