SECTIONS CLOSE
  • Home
  • Directory
    • Artists
    • Black Youth & Family Services
    • Books
    • Business
    • Films
    • Politicians
  • Jobs
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
    • Books
    • Film & TV
    • Music
    • Stage
  • Events
    • Submit an Event
  • The Experts
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Legal
    • Marketing
    • Money
    • Motivation
    • Parenting
    • Real Estate
    • Sex & Relationships
    • Technology
    • Travel
  • Profiles
    • Artists
    • Business
    • NFP/Charities
    • Personalities
    • Food & Drink
    • Sponsored Profiles
  • BRW
    • BRW Restaurant Signup
  • PCA
    • 2022 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2021 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2020 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2019 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
    • 2018 ByBlacks.com PCA Winners List
  • Archive
  • Newsletter Archive
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Editorial
  • General
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sales
  • User Login

ByBlacks.com | #1 online magazine for Black Canadians

Legal

Gay Man Still Fighting For His Right To Donate Blood

Gay Man Still Fighting For His Right To Donate Blood
Walker Law Professional Corporation By Walker Law Professional Corporation
Published on Saturday, June 11, 2022 - 16:07
On August 15, 2016, Christopher Karas, a gay man living in Ontario, brought a claim to the Canada Human Rights Tribunal that Health Canada and Canadian Blood Services were discriminating against him because of his sexual orientation. His claim was based on the policies refusing blood donations from men who have had sex with a male partner over the past year. This was changed to three months since the start of Mr. Karas’ lawsuit.

The Canadian Blood Services screening process for donations requires donors to complete a questionnaire; then, every blood sample is tested. The questionnaire is designed to screen donors who have engaged in recent activity that put them at a higher risk of contracting a bloodborne pathogen to decrease the risk of infected blood being accepted.

According to Stanford Health Care, anal sex is the sexual activity with the highest chance of transmission if exposed to HIV. Also, according to Canadian Blood Services, men who have sex with male partners account for 50% of all new HIV infections. The current policy of Canadian Blood Services is to not accept donations of blood from men who have had sex with a male partner within the past three months because it is seen as a high-risk activity for contracting HIV. This is colloquially known as “the MSM Policy.”

Mr. Karas specifically claimed that he was being discriminated against under section 5 of the Canadian Human Rights Act, which prohibits denial of services on prohibited grounds. Sexual orientation is considered a prohibited ground under the Canadian Human Rights Act.

Mr. Karas’ case is still ongoing. Recently, the Canada Human Rights Commission ordered an inquiry by the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal to investigate Health Canada’s role in the processes related to the screening policy. Human rights commissions in Canada request inquiries where there is merit to a discrimination claim. After the inquiry is complete, the case will go to the tribunal to decide whether there is discrimination. Tanya Walker of Walker Law Professional Corporation described the inquiry as being like the police and the tribunal being like the court. Tanya’s City TV interview on discrimination while donating blood can be found here.

The Federal Court decided that the Commission’s decision to order an inquiry was reasonable and allowed the inquiry to proceed.

{https://twitter.com/TylerKBoyce/status/1520617420607696897}

Canadian Blood Services also recognizes that its donor health questions have disproportionately impacted racialized Canadians due to their geography-based policies. For example, the questionnaire asks potential donors if they were born in Mexico, Central America, or South America to “determine the risk of exposure to Chagas disease.” In addition, the decision of the Federal Court in Mr. Karas’ lawsuit suggests that racialized potential donors could bring a claim against Canadian Blood Services or Health Canada for discriminatory barriers to donating blood.

Since Mr. Karas started his challenge of the MSM policy, Canadian Blood Services have modified its questionnaire criteria. The new measures, effective on September 30, 2022, will ask all donors about anal sex with new or recent partners, regardless of sexual orientation. 

It means everyone will be asked whether they have recently engaged in anal sex in the context of new or multiple sexual partners within the last few months. If they have, they would not be able to donate until they had gone three months without engaging in that activity.

It is unclear whether the new policy will be upheld under the Canadian Human Rights Act. While the questionnaire no longer refers specifically to men who have sex with other men, the gay community will be unequally affected by the requirement that the donor not have had anal sex with a partner for the previous three months. This could still present an unequal, discriminatory barrier for gay men wishing to donate blood. Canadian Blood Services and Health Canada could face challenges from racialized groups, the gay community, and possibly others in the future for their possible discriminatory screening policies.

Last modified on Thursday, June 16, 2022 - 13:07

Featured Directory Listings

  • CADJPro Payroll Solutions
    CADJPro Payroll...www.cadjpro.comName: CADJPro Payroll Solutions
  • Zarie Lorne Professional Corporation | Barristers & Solicitors
    Zarie Lorne...Name: Zarie Lorne Professional Corporation | Barristers & Sol...
  • Walker Law | Professional Corporation
    Walker Law |...tcwalkerlawyers.com...Name: Walker Law | Professional Corporation
  • Cleve DeSouza P.Eng., PMP Mortgage Agent Canfin Mortgage & Equity Inc. Brokerage Lic. 11949
    Cleve DeSouza...https:/...Name: Cleve DeSouza P.Eng., PMP Mortgage Agent Canfin Mortgag...
  • Konvo Media Inc.
    Konvo Media Inc.www.konvomedia.comName: Konvo Media Inc.
  • SEE ALL LISTINGS
  • LGBTQ
  • HUMAN RIGHTS
  • PRIDE MONTH
  • PRIDE
Walker Law Professional Corporation By Walker Law Professional Corporation

Latest from Walker Law Professional Corporation

  • Canada Increases Protection For Foreign Workers
  • Human Rights Tribunal Awards Compensation For Discriminatory Practices Found In Police Investigation
  • How Canada's Housing Bubble Is Hampering Our Basic Human Rights
  • Emancipation Day: How Did Canadian Courts Help To Phase Out Slavery?
  • The Risks Of Backing Out Of A Real Estate Transaction

MORE IN THIS CATEGORY

The Risks Of Backing Out Of A Real Estate Transaction
The Risks Of Backing Out Of A Real Estate Transaction 30 May 2022
Emancipation Day: How Did Canadian Courts Help To Phase Out Slavery? 09 July 2022
Emancipation Day: How Did Canadian Courts Help To Phase Out Slavery?

RELATED STORIES

Why You’ll Fall On Your Knees For Award-Winning Actor Amaka Umeh

Why You’ll Fall On Your Knees For Award-Winning Actor Amaka Umeh

25 January 2023
Canada Increases Protection For Foreign Workers

Canada Increases Protection For Foreign Workers

27 October 2022
How Canada's Housing Bubble Is Hampering Our Basic Human Rights

How Canada's Housing Bubble Is Hampering Our Basic Human Rights

22 August 2022
ByBlacks.com | #1 online magazine for Black Canadians
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Editorial
  • General
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sales
  • User Login
Copyright © 2013 - 2023 ByBlacks.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
developed by Nuevvo